Something Sweet is Here!

Taste Them All

Measuring, mixing, rolling, baking and decorating...every loving step brings back memories of mom's kitchen.  And childhood favorites have become family recipes handed down for another generation. Check out some of our favorites as well as our customer's...then treat yourself! Our hope is you are reminded of a sweet memory or two ...or that we become your new guilty pleasure!

This represents just a small sampling of sweetness we can create.  We rotate items in the bakery regularly...don't see your favorite? Stay current with 'Today's Flavors', or message us for a special request!


Decorated Cookies

Our decorated sugar cookies are our signature item and are occasionally available in-store and by limited custom order. Each cookie is handcrafted with beautiful detail and, yes, they taste as good as they look! Our most popular flavor is our signature butter-vanilla, but we occasionally brighten it up with the addition of lemon zest, plus we also offer other delicious flavor options such as chocolate brownie, chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, coconut almond, fruity pebble, birthday cake and strawberry lemonade. All paired with our flavorful, soft bite royal icing.

See Cookie page for info on ordering custom cookies. CURRENTLY BOOKED FOR CUSTOM COOKIE ORDERS FOR 2021.


Breads, Cupcakes & Muffins

From quick breads to the rustic flavors of golden brown and crusty yeast breads, Sweet Baby J's offers something sweet and a little decadent for all occasions. Lemon-blueberry Bread with Lemon Vanilla Bean Icing is a fan favorite - moist and tender bursting with flavor. Banana Nut bread is a close second. And how about cupcakes? Red Velvet, Churro and German Chocolate cupcakes top the list of handheld sweetness...and of course, Funfetti! So much goodness might require an intervention!

Cupcakes are available for custom order by the dozen:

Standard Vanilla, Chocolate &  Funfetti -  $42*/dozen

Specialty Flavors: Red Velvet, German Chocolate, Churro, Carrot, Black Forest, Turtle, Strawberry Truffle, Lemon Meringue, S'mores, Nutella Pretzel, Strawberries 'n Cream, Boston Creme Pie, Banana Split, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Snickerdoodle - $48*/dozen

Seasonal Flavors: Pumpkin Spice, Apple Crisp, Chocolate Peppermint - $48*/dozen

Other Specialty Flavors: Guinness, Margarita - $54*/dozen

(some flavors may be limited by seasonal ingredients)

*$3 per dozen discount for orders placed with at least 7 days notice (subject to availability).

Love Red Velvet and Carrot...can't decide on flavor? How about 2 flavors? 

Split Fee (per additional flavor) $5 

(must be from same price tier or individual pricing applies - 2 flavors per dozen)


Bars, Brownies & Drop Cookies

What's better than a fresh from the oven chocolate chip cookie? Not much, unless it's 2 chocolate chip cookies!  We offer them with or without pecans. Not a chocolate fan? Be sure to try our popular Smash Cookie - a shortbread cookie frosted with Raspberry  and NEW Blueberry Buttercream. Our Galaxy Brownies take this Little Debbie snack to the next level. Black & White Cookies, Oatmeal Creme and Whoopie Pies...whoopie!! Our next-level Rice Krispie Treats are a mash-up of your favorite treats - Samoa and Reese's Pieces. All this goodness must not go to waste...not to be confused with 'waist' lol! And most items are available by special order as well.


Puddings, Parfaits & Other Desserts

What can be more of a comfort food than Banana Pudding? And this is not your everyday pudding cup...creamy, sweet pudding made with real cream, is layered with fresh bananas and crunchy vanilla wafers...don't forget a spoon! Other refreshing desserts include Key Lime Pie, Chocolate Eclair Cake, Sopaipilla Cheesecake, Cannolis and more.

Available for custom order:

Banana Pudding - 32 oz/$16

Strawberry Cheesecake Pudding (seasonal) -

32 oz/$18

Key Lime Pie - 10" deep dish/$40

Black Forest Cake_edited.jpg

Classic Cakes

Classic cakes such as German Chocolate and Carrot are always a hit for any occasion...and our specialty cakes, like S'mores and Turtle, will take your dessert to the next level! By the slice in the bakery when available or whole desserts by custom order.

Whole Cakes (6"-3 layer) available by order:

Red Velvet Cake - $50

German Chocolate, Carrot, Italian Creme - $52

S'mores, Black Forest Cake, Turtle, Nutella, Margarita - $58

Other sizes and flavors may be available upon request.



We make a variety of these dainty French sandwich cookies that are really just magical, if not mythical! A delicate and airy meringue shell sandwiches a variety of fillings such as flavored buttercream, ganache, or fruity jams or preserves. Our signature Raspberry Habanero flavor is the perfect mixture of sweet and spicy with a cream cheese buttercream surrounding just the perfect touch of Raspberry Habanero jelly. Other favorites include Lemon Blueberry, Margarita, Nutella, Salted Caramel and Fruity Pebbles.

Custom Order Flavors Available by the dozen...limit 1 flavor per dozen.

Pricing starts at $36/dozen



Smooth, creamy and oh so luscious...who doesn't love a good cheesecake? Plain or paired with your favorite topping - salted caramel, cherry, strawberry, blueberry or real whipped cream - it's hard to top this dense, rich dessert that's perfect for any occasion or just a date with your fork!

Available for custom order plain, with sauce/filling or specialty flavors. 

7" Plain Cheesecake - $35

9" Plain Cheesecake - $40

Salted Caramel Sauce, 8 oz - $10

Cherry or Strawberry Topping, 16 oz - $10

Inquire about pricing:

Turtle Cheesecake

Pumpkin Cheesecake

Pecan Pie Cheesecake

eZy Watermark_28-02-2021_11-26-17PM.jpg

Cookie Toppers

Hmmmm...cupcakes? Cookies? How about both - a cupcake topped with a decorated mini cookie?! Choose your favorite flavor cake - white, chocolate, red velvet, pumpkin spice, cinnamon, german chocolate, carrot, add a coordinating frosting - vanilla, chocolate or cinnamon buttercream, cream cheese buttercream, coconut pecan, and top with a decorated cookie that fits your theme.

Pricing starts at $60/dozen

Got a craving? We’ve got what you want right here. Stop by to see what's available each week or contact us for a custom request.

Effective immediately (May 2021), ALL custom orders (for any item) may be subject to a rush fee of $25 if placed less than 7 days before requested pickup. Rush orders are subject to availability and may not be possible.